Introduction

Afternoon tea is more than a meal—it’s a ritual, a moment of calm amid the rush of daily life. In Columbus, Ohio, a quiet but vibrant culture of tea appreciation has taken root, blending British tradition with Midwestern warmth. From elegant hotel lounges to cozy neighborhood tea rooms, the city offers a surprising array of venues where quality, ambiance, and authenticity come together. But not all tea experiences are created equal. With so many options, how do you know which ones truly deliver on flavor, service, and atmosphere? This guide highlights the top 10 afternoon tea spots in Columbus you can trust—venues consistently praised for their craftsmanship, consistency, and care. These are not just popular; they are dependable. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, hosting a friend, or simply treating yourself, these selections offer an afternoon tea experience you can rely on, time and again.

Why Trust Matters

When choosing an afternoon tea spot, trust isn’t a luxury—it’s a necessity. Unlike a quick coffee run or a casual lunch, afternoon tea is an experience built on sensory details: the crispness of freshly baked scones, the aroma of steeped loose-leaf tea, the elegance of fine china, and the attentiveness of staff who understand the rhythm of the ritual. A single disappointing visit—overpriced tea bags, stale pastries, or indifferent service—can tarnish the entire tradition. Trust is earned through consistency. It’s the result of a venue that prioritizes quality over quantity, sourcing premium ingredients, training staff in tea etiquette, and maintaining an environment that honors the ceremony. In Columbus, where dining trends shift rapidly and new establishments open weekly, only a handful have demonstrated the discipline and dedication to uphold the standards of true afternoon tea. These are the places where regulars return, where visitors leave with glowing reviews, and where the tea is always perfect, the scones always warm, and the service always thoughtful. Trust isn’t just about reputation—it’s about reliability. And in a world where experiences are fleeting, finding a spot you can trust makes all the difference.

Top 10 Afternoon Tea Spots in Columbus

1. The Ritz-Carlton, Columbus – The Grand Tea Room

Set within one of Columbus’s most iconic luxury hotels, The Ritz-Carlton’s Grand Tea Room offers an afternoon tea experience that rivals those in London and New York. The setting is timeless: crystal chandeliers, plush velvet seating, and white linen tablecloths create an atmosphere of refined elegance. The tea selection features over 40 single-origin varieties, sourced directly from estates in Darjeeling, Ceylon, and Yunnan. Each tiered stand is artfully arranged with finger sandwiches crafted daily—cucumber dill, smoked salmon with chive cream cheese, and egg salad with truffle oil—alongside scones baked in-house, served with clotted cream and house-made preserves. The staff are trained in tea sommelier techniques, guiding guests through pairings and brewing methods. Reservations are required, and the experience is offered Friday through Sunday, making it a cherished weekend tradition for locals and out-of-town guests alike. The attention to detail—from the temperature of the teapot to the placement of the napkin—reflects a deep respect for the ritual.

2. The Tea Room at The LeVeque Tower

Nestled in the historic LeVeque Tower, this intimate tea room blends early 20th-century architecture with modern sophistication. The space features soaring ceilings, ornate moldings, and stained-glass windows that cast colorful patterns across the tables during afternoon light. The menu rotates seasonally, emphasizing local Ohio ingredients: heirloom apple jam from a nearby orchard, artisanal cheeses from Amish farms, and lavender-infused shortbread made by a Columbus bakery. Their signature blend, “Columbus Bloom,” combines Earl Grey with local honey and dried rose petals. Scones are served warm, with a choice of traditional or gluten-free options, and the tea service includes a small tasting of three different infusions before your main selection. The staff, many of whom have worked here for over a decade, remember regulars’ preferences and often surprise guests with a complimentary treat. The Tea Room at The LeVeque Tower is not just a place to drink tea—it’s a living piece of Columbus history.

3. The Garden Tea House at Franklin Park Conservatory

One of the most unique afternoon tea experiences in the city takes place within the lush, glass-domed conservatory of Franklin Park. The Garden Tea House offers a serene, nature-immersed setting where guests sip tea surrounded by orchids, ferns, and seasonal floral displays. The menu is plant-forward and thoughtfully curated: cucumber-mint sandwiches, quinoa salad bites, and vegan scones made with oat milk and maple syrup. Tea selections include organic, fair-trade blends from around the world, with a special focus on herbal infusions like chamomile-blossom and hibiscus-ginger. The experience includes a guided tasting of three teas, each paired with a small edible flower or herb from the conservatory’s gardens. It’s an ideal choice for those seeking a tranquil, health-conscious tea experience. The conservatory’s commitment to sustainability extends to the tea service—reusable ceramic ware, compostable packaging, and zero single-use plastics. This is afternoon tea with a conscience.

4. The Porch Tea & Co.

Located in the heart of the Short North, The Porch Tea & Co. brings a modern, bohemian twist to the classic afternoon tea. The space is bright and airy, with mismatched vintage china, hanging plants, and walls adorned with local artwork. Their tea menu is extensive, featuring house-blended flavors like “Columbus Spice” (black tea with cardamom, orange peel, and cinnamon) and “Midwest Mint” (peppermint and spearmint grown in nearby greenhouses). The scones are legendary—moist, golden, and served with house-churned butter and seasonal fruit compotes. Sandwiches are inventive: smoked trout with horseradish crème fraîche, roasted beet and goat cheese on rye, and a vegan jackfruit “chicken” salad. The staff are passionate about tea culture and often host free weekly tea tastings for guests. The Porch Tea & Co. appeals to younger crowds without sacrificing authenticity. It’s a place where tradition meets creativity, and every detail—from the hand-written tea notes to the curated playlist—feels intentional.

5. The Victorian Tea Room at The Inn at Irish Bend

Just a short drive from downtown, The Inn at Irish Bend offers a true Victorian-era afternoon tea experience. The tea room is decorated in period-appropriate furnishings: lace curtains, mahogany sideboards, and porcelain teapots from the 1800s. The menu follows strict British conventions: crustless cucumber sandwiches, miniature meat pies, and scones served with amber honey and strawberry jam made from fruit picked on the property. Tea is brewed in silver pots and poured with ceremonial precision. The staff wear period-inspired attire, and the experience is accompanied by live classical piano music on weekends. Reservations are limited to small groups to preserve the intimate atmosphere. This is not a restaurant—it’s a time capsule. Guests often describe it as “like stepping into a Jane Austen novel.” For those seeking the most authentic British-style afternoon tea in Ohio, this is the gold standard.

6. The Lily & Thistle Tea House

Founded by a British expat and a local tea enthusiast, The Lily & Thistle Tea House is a labor of love that has become a Columbus institution. The space is cozy and warmly lit, with shelves lined with tea tins from around the globe. The menu features a rotating selection of 15+ teas, each described with tasting notes and origin stories. Their “Afternoon Classic” includes finger sandwiches (egg salad with chives, smoked turkey with cranberry mustard), warm scones with Devonshire cream, and a trio of desserts: lemon drizzle cake, chocolate truffles, and raspberry macarons. What sets them apart is their commitment to transparency: every tea is brewed to order, and staff can tell you the exact harvest date and elevation of the leaves. They also offer tea education workshops for guests who want to deepen their knowledge. The Lily & Thistle has earned a loyal following for its sincerity and attention to detail. It’s the kind of place where you leave not just satisfied, but enlightened.

7. The Botanist Tea Parlor

Blending tea with botanical science, The Botanist Tea Parlor offers an intellectual yet indulgent afternoon experience. The space resembles a 19th-century apothecary, with glass jars of dried herbs, essential oils, and tea leaves displayed like specimens. Each tea is paired with a “flavor profile card” explaining its botanical origins and health properties. The scones are infused with edible flowers like borage and calendula, and the sandwiches include foraged greens from Ohio woodlands. Their signature “Forest Floor” blend combines black tea with pine needle, wild mushroom, and juniper berry. Guests can choose a “tea journey”—a curated tasting of five teas, each paired with a small bite designed to enhance the flavor notes. The staff are trained in herbalism and often share stories about the plants they source. This is afternoon tea as an exploration—a thoughtful, sensory journey through nature and tradition.

8. The Hearth & Teapot

Located in the historic German Village neighborhood, The Hearth & Teapot combines German culinary heritage with English tea tradition. The ambiance is rustic-chic: exposed brick, wooden beams, and a large stone fireplace that’s lit during cooler months. The menu features savory tea sandwiches with German influences—schnitzel sliders, spiced cabbage rolls, and caraway-seeded rye bread with butter and honey. Scones are made with buttermilk and topped with sour cherry compote. Their tea list includes rare German herbal infusions like chamomile from Bavaria and linden blossom from the Black Forest. The tea service is accompanied by live accordion music on Sundays, adding a touch of European charm. The Hearth & Teapot is a favorite among locals who appreciate its authenticity, warmth, and the sense of community it fosters. It’s not just a tea room—it’s a gathering place.

9. The Silver Teapot

With a name that evokes elegance and timelessness, The Silver Teapot has been a Columbus staple for over 25 years. Located in a restored 1920s bungalow, the tea room is filled with antiques, family heirlooms, and soft candlelight. The tea selection is curated by the owner, a certified tea master with over 40 years of experience. Her signature “Columbus Legacy Blend” is a proprietary mix of Assam, Ceylon, and a touch of Darjeeling, served in fine bone china that has been in her family for generations. The scones are baked daily using a 100-year-old recipe passed down from her grandmother. Sandwiches are simple but perfect: egg salad with chives, dill pickles, and smoked salmon on thinly sliced rye. The service is unhurried, personal, and deeply respectful. Regulars often say they come not just for the tea, but for the feeling of being cared for. The Silver Teapot is a quiet gem—unassuming, consistent, and utterly trustworthy.

10. The Willow & Wren Tea Room

Located in the up-and-coming Clintonville neighborhood, The Willow & Wren offers a modern, minimalist take on afternoon tea. The space is light-filled, with clean lines, neutral tones, and a focus on natural materials—wood, linen, and ceramic. The tea program is exceptional, featuring small-batch, single-estate teas from Japan, Taiwan, and Kenya. Their “Tea & Pastry Pairing” includes a curated flight of three teas matched with three small desserts: matcha financiers, blackberry rose tarts, and white chocolate chai cookies. Sandwiches are artfully plated: heirloom tomato with basil oil, smoked duck with fig jam, and avocado mousse on sprouted grain bread. The staff are knowledgeable without being pretentious, and the atmosphere is relaxed yet refined. The Willow & Wren appeals to those who appreciate subtlety, balance, and quiet luxury. It’s the perfect spot for a mindful afternoon, whether you’re meeting a friend or enjoying solitude with a good book.

Comparison Table

FAQs

What makes an afternoon tea experience trustworthy?

A trustworthy afternoon tea experience is defined by consistency in quality, authenticity in service, and attention to detail. It’s not about flashy décor or high prices—it’s about well-brewed tea, freshly baked scones, thoughtful pairings, and staff who understand the ritual. Trust is built over time through repeat visits where every element—from the temperature of the water to the presentation of the china—remains impeccable.

Do I need to dress up for afternoon tea in Columbus?

Dress codes vary by venue. At luxury locations like The Ritz-Carlton or The Victorian Tea Room, smart casual or elegant attire is expected. At more relaxed spots like The Porch Tea & Co. or The Willow & Wren, neat casual clothing is perfectly acceptable. When in doubt, check the venue’s website or call ahead—most places appreciate guests who dress respectfully for the occasion.

Are there vegan or gluten-free options available?

Yes, most of the top tea spots in Columbus offer vegan and gluten-free alternatives. The Garden Tea House at Franklin Park Conservatory and The Willow & Wren specialize in plant-based menus. The Tea Room at The LeVeque Tower and The Porch Tea & Co. provide clear labeling and customizable options. Always inform the staff of dietary needs when booking—many venues prepare special items in advance.

Can I book afternoon tea for a group?

Absolutely. All ten venues welcome group bookings, though some require advance notice for parties larger than four. The Ritz-Carlton, The Victorian Tea Room, and The Garden Tea House have dedicated group menus and private rooms. Smaller spots like The Lily & Thistle and The Silver Teapot may have limited availability for large groups, so planning ahead is essential.

Is afternoon tea expensive in Columbus?

Prices range from $35 to $75 per person, depending on the venue and the level of service. Luxury hotels charge more due to the full-service experience, while neighborhood tea rooms offer excellent value with smaller, focused menus. Many consider it a worthwhile splurge for special occasions or a meaningful treat for oneself.

Can I take tea home from these spots?

Most of the top tea spots sell their signature blends in-store or online. The Lily & Thistle, The Botanist Tea Parlor, and The Silver Teapot offer beautifully packaged teas for purchase. Some even provide custom blending services for gifts. Taking home a tea you loved is a wonderful way to extend the experience.

Is afternoon tea available year-round?

Yes. All ten venues offer afternoon tea throughout the year. Some, like The Garden Tea House, adjust their menu seasonally to highlight fresh ingredients. Winter months often feature spiced teas and warming pastries, while spring and summer bring floral infusions and light sandwiches. Reservations are recommended year-round due to popularity.

Can children attend afternoon tea?

Most venues welcome children, especially during weekend services. The Ritz-Carlton and The Victorian Tea Room offer children’s tea menus with smaller portions and kid-friendly options. The Porch Tea & Co. and The Garden Tea House are particularly welcoming to families. Always confirm with the venue if you’re bringing young guests, as some intimate spaces may have age recommendations.

What’s the best time to go for afternoon tea?

Traditional afternoon tea is served between 2:00 PM and 4:00 PM. This is when the full experience—sandwiches, scones, and desserts—is available. Some venues offer extended hours or early/late slots for private events. Arriving at the start of the service ensures the freshest food and the most attentive service.

How far in advance should I book?

For popular venues like The Ritz-Carlton, The Victorian Tea Room, or The Garden Tea House, book at least two weeks in advance—especially on weekends or holidays. Smaller spots like The Silver Teapot or The Lily & Thistle may accept bookings a few days ahead. Walk-ins are rarely accommodated, so planning ahead ensures your spot.

Conclusion

In Columbus, afternoon tea is not a passing trend—it’s a cherished tradition, quietly cultivated by passionate individuals who believe in the power of a well-brewed cup and a moment of stillness. The ten spots highlighted here are not chosen for their popularity alone, but for their unwavering commitment to excellence. Each one offers something unique: the grandeur of The Ritz-Carlton, the history of The LeVeque Tower, the serenity of Franklin Park, the creativity of The Porch Tea & Co., the authenticity of The Victorian Tea Room, the knowledge of The Lily & Thistle, the botanical depth of The Botanist Tea Parlor, the charm of The Hearth & Teapot, the timeless warmth of The Silver Teapot, and the refined simplicity of The Willow & Wren. These are the places you return to—not because they’re the most advertised, but because they never disappoint. Trust is earned slowly, and these venues have earned it, one perfect scone, one carefully poured cup, one thoughtful gesture at a time. Whether you’re a lifelong tea lover or a curious newcomer, these ten spots offer more than a meal—they offer a sanctuary. So slow down, pour yourself a cup, and savor the moment. In a world that moves too fast, Columbus’s best afternoon tea spots remind us how to pause—and how to be truly present.